Some student questions about Pericles' Funeral Speech, Day 1 (9/13/2000)
These are questions from
my fall, 2000 Intellectual Heritage Class after one session on the Funeral
Speech. They may be a guide to what
to expect in other sections. --DPT
1. How did women react to all of the
male-charged aspects of Athenian
democracy? What is women's role in the speech?
2. "I'm sure what's most confusing is stuff that I'm entirely unaware of..."
3. "Athenian democracy is shady. I get
it but it's weird.... I had to read
some passages several times."
4. Democracy and the empire.
5. Distinctions between different sorts of parents.
6. What *are* the guiding metaphors?
7. "Was Pericles mocking Athens?""I'm
confused about the tone the speaker is
using."
8. How did Athens compare to the rest of the ancient world?
9. "How do the Athenians consider themselves
a democracy? They show no
evidence of being a democracy." (There
were other questions about democracy,
too.)
10. A few students said they understood
more in the class than in the group
work.
11. What war is this? Why were they fighting?
12. I'm still confused about chapter
42; I'm not sure what is *distinctive*
about AThens.
13. "Athenian democracy is not exactly
equality for all but somehow more
imperialistic. I'm quite disheartened."
14. "I still don't understand Pericles'
motives. It is supposed to be a
eulogy, but it does not seem like one.
It seems as though Pericles talks more
about nationalism/patriotism than about the
dead. Why?"
What this class considered important:
1. class discussion; get other people's views.
2. direct rather than vague questions from the teacher
3. using the text to illustrate points.
4. going over the text.